Saturday, September 26, 2020
Butch ripoff
Queering the Great Rite Workshop at Pantheacon
I felt hemmed in by her preconceptions. For her, there was ONE WAY to use the Chalice and the Blade, and I will say that I have never participated in a 'Fucking the Cup' ritual, as a Lesbian Separatist Dianic friend of mine whose been around in the Pagan community says...it always seemed rather distasteful to me, and entirely heterosexist. Nor was an altar cloth set out, candles, or even a meditation on imagining our immense diversity of experiences as Lesbian/Gay/Queer folks, and how we combine our Sexuality and Spirituality together in a Sacred Way.
LESBIAN AND FEMALE SOLIDARITY
"We understand that political solidarity between females expressed in sisterhood goes beyond positive recognition of the experiences of women and even shared sympathy for common suffering. Feminist sisterhood is rooted in shared commitment to struggle against patriarchal injustice, no matter the form that injustice takes. Political solidarity between women always undermines sexism and sets the stage for the overthrow of patriarchy." --bell hooks
Made me think of
Listening to Lesbians: Same Sex Attraction is not bigotry
Listening to Lesbians our voices matter
Banning lesbians – same sex attraction is not bigotry
I have avoided writing about this because I know what the reaction can be like and I have seen what happens to women who do speak publicly about this.
I have tried quite hard to discuss various issues WITHOUT addressing this because it is polarising, causes people to stop thinking, and leads to abuse and harassment. Moreover it is difficult to write anything nuanced on this topic without people misinterpreting and wilfully misrepresenting your words. And then there’s the ever-so-trendy hate that rains down on those that state publicly what others keep quiet about.
But I know that not writing about this is being silenced. I have “allowed” myself to be silenced on this just as many other women have, because of potential fallout.
And there is no amount of staying quiet that can keep us safe as lesbians, because there is an attempt from some to redefine the word lesbian to exclude us.
This includes a clear attempt to coercively redraw lesbian women’s sexual boundaries and to silence the lesbians who protest this.
I have no interest in defining and complicating others’ lives* but words have meanings and language matters.
We cannot stay silent while we are told that we are bigots for being lesbian.
To be a lesbian is to be a female who is romantically, emotionally and sexually attracted to other females. This is same-sex attraction.
There are those who argue a different definition of this word.
The debate hinges on
a) whether you think transwomen are women or not**
and
b) whether you think sexuality is attraction on the basis of gender*** or sex
If you think that sexuality is about same SEX attraction, you may have noticed something going on.
Women who say that they are lesbian and ONLY attracted to females are being told they are bigots, and are being abused on this basis.
I don’t care if women are attracted to (and in relationships with) transwomen but what concerns me is the use of the word lesbian to describe that relationship because of the implications for same-sex attracted lesbians. My interest is solely caused by the implications for same-sex attracted lesbians of that language use – this is about the difference between self-affecting acts and other-affecting acts.
There are real consequences if the word lesbian includes transwomen.
When those of us who are same-sex attracted lesbians try to describe ourselves, our relationships or our sexuality, what word are we to use if we cannot use ‘lesbian’? If the word used for some time to describe us, as understood by most people, is no longer representative of us what language are we to use?
More than this, if the word lesbian cannot be used in a context that excludes transwomen then we are even more marginalised. And this is what I see happening, this is what has happened to women I know, what has happened to me.
Lesbians are being told they are bigots, transphobes, transmysogynists and TERFs for considering itACCEPTABLE for lesbians to be solely attracted to other females.
Originally when this was not such an extreme situation, I was not as concerned, assuming that using the word ‘female’ to specify same-sex attraction would be sufficient and unproblematic.
However, this is now a problem for two reasons. Firstly, any number of transwomen define themselves as female, rendering the qualifier useless in some conversations. But for those who consider the word female to denote biological sex, it is apparently unacceptable to exclude “non-female lesbians”.
In a lesbian group, amongst lesbians, I was told that it is transphobic for lesbians to be solely attracted to females. It is not a sexuality, apparently, it is a bigotry!! This happens repeatedly to lesbians around the world.
Lesbians must be able to name our own reality and we need that word to describe female-to-female same-sex attraction. We have no other word.
For centuries we have been socially sanctioned for our sexuality, we have been closeted, persecuted, abused, correctively raped, and killed, solely on the basis of being lesbian. Compulsory heterosexuality has weighed heavily on us, and we have borne the burden of oppression as women AND as lesbians.
And now we find that, in a lesbian community, being a dyke is suddenly outlawed?
In what way is this not just the continuation of compulsory heterosexuality?
When we are told that not being attracted to someone who was born male**** is immoral, this is exactly the same as being told that we are deviants for attraction to women and non-attraction to men, but it is now clothed in language that frames and proclaims us as oppressive for acknowledging biological facts and our own sexuality.
I see young lesbians confused by this, trying to do the “right” thing. Baby dykes asking if being lesbian CANmean only being attracted to females, trying hard to be inclusive even in their own sexual experiences.
That women are still asking if sexual boundaries are acceptable means that the rape culture which constantly erodes and undermines women’s sexual boundaries and attacks
FeistyAmazon on 05/07/2015 at 2:19 am
Reblogged this on FeistyAmazon and commented:
Love love LOVE this!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!!!-FeistyAmazon
Rite of Passage
Hormones, binding her breasts severely, flattening them to the world but wounding heart and lungs in the process?
Instead of coming into her youthful powerful fiery Amazonism she is trying to erase the Female from her body, the womonness from her mind, killing her female soul?
Being convinced she must have her breasts shorn from her body like so many strands of hair.
We Butches of the 70s and 80s settled for cutting our hair and wearing it short. It would always grow back...we claimed our Female Power, honored it at Festivals, at play parties, at women's houses, in the Mountains, under the Moons ad Stars with our Wild and Lovely Dyke Sisters!!!
Lesbians were dipped in chocolate, skinny dipped in streams and rivers, lakes and oceans, we danced and drummed our Female Power at bonfires in the woods....we Traveled to distant stars and came back..through an orgasm, a song, a chant, a roar, to the beat of the drum ruling our Wild Female Hearts!!!We KNEW OUR POWER, WITH EACH OTHER!!
Sisters who could see inside our WomonSouls to the depths of our Oceanic Female Selves.....
"Warrior Goddess" my response taken from a post at Medusa Coils
Ruth Bader Ginsburg
There is a family connection to her death. Not only do I feel connected to RBG being a Bew York Jew born and raised,my father grew up the same time as her in Brooklyn and graduated in the same class as her from Cornell. He too, did his post grad at Columbia University.
Like RGB, my Jewish Grandmother broke ground by becoming a School Principal for a public school in Brooklyn, before women were promoted to this position. I came up in NYC Feminism from the influence of strong women around me, from 1969 on, only being 9 years old. I heard the older girls talking about all this.
Women who believed in themselves, each other and in pursuing their careers and lives, in persisting and not being held back by men or patriarchal institutions and who persevered like RBG did, and my Grandmother, and Shirley Chisolm running for President! Such women were and are a deep inspiration to me!
It enabled me to pursue my Black Belt, and a career in the Trades. The laws Ruth Bader Ginsburg helped pass or supported in her work, enabled us to have our own careers, apartments, credit cards and independence AS independent Females, without needing male approval or males to sign for us.
I sure hope we can ADD to her legacy and her last wishes that herseat remain empty until after the new President is inaugurated.
Lets visualize her overlooking that seat along with Lilith, that it STAY EMPTY to such time that our new President BIDEN is inaugurated!! SO MOTE IT BE!!!
- The feistiest of AMAZONS